10 Best Fish to Catch in New York

This post contains affiliate links, and I will be compensated if you make a purchase after clicking on my links, at no cost to you.

New York is considered one of the top attractions for tourists from all over the world. From the splendid times square to breathtaking Niagara Falls, New York never disappoints its visitors. However, along with offering some amazing spots for adventurous visitors, New York also offers a list of fishing enthusiasts’ locations. And above all, it is home to some of the dreamiest fish species, making it even more desirable for anglers.

In this article, we have picked the ten best fish to catch in New York. Let’s study these fish species.

1. Panfish

Panfishes are some of the top fishes in New York. This state is filled with panfish, including crappie, yellow perch, bluegill, rock bass, white perch, pumpkinseed, and white bass. According to anglers, live baits are most effective for catching various types of panfish here. You will find these species in almost all of the waters throughout the state.

2. Atlantic Salmon

Atlantic Salmon is considered a tough catch by anglers. You will hardly find one in the waters. But these are some of the top targets here, especially for those who love challenging fishes. Some famous spots for catching Atlantic salmon in New York includes Lake Ontario, Niagara River, Eighteen Mile Creek, and Burt Dam.  Try your luck in these waters; most of the anglers have found their dream catch here.

3. Brown Trout

The state record for Brown Trout is 33-pounds. However, you can easily find a 30-pound brown trout in the waters here. The season for trout starts in April and ends in August. While some of the famous water bodies for brown trout include Lake Ontario, Burt Dam, Twelve Mile Creek, a Lower portion of Niagara River, and the inland streams in Erie County.

4. Bullhead

For bullheads, you should always head towards the Niagara area. The waters of the Niagara River are full of bullheads, especially during springtime. You will surely catch a basket full of them. These species have sharp spines on pectoral and dorsal fins. So, be cautious while targeting them. To increase your catch, it is better to use crabs, minnows, worms, dough balls, etc.

5. Carp

Carp is one of the prize-winning catches of anglers in New York. The Niagara Area is also famous for its population of Carp. Anglers from Europe love catching Carp here. A tourist angler also caught the 40-pounds state recorded Carp from Europe. Moreover, you can also find a good quantity of these fishes in Ontario and Erie Bays, especially the Erie Canal System.

6. Channel Catfish

Channel Catfish is famous among the local anglers. The state recorded channel catfish was caught years ago in Lake Erie. However, you can still find plenty of these species here. Additionally, anglers also head to the Great Lakes waters for catching channel catfish. You will also find plenty of them there too.

7. Chinook Salmon

Chinook is the second most famous type of salmon found in New York. The fishing season for these fish species start in April and end in November. These are often found in Lake Ontario. However, some other water bodies are popular for chinook salmon, like Niagara River, Lake Erie, and Olcott. The state record for chinook salmon is 47 pounds.

8. Coho Salmon

Lake Ontario is highly popular for its Coho salmon population. The world record of Coho Salmon was also caught in the same lake. Moreover, Lake Erie, Piers at Olcott and Wilson also contain a good amount of coho salmon. So, if it is your dream catch, then you must head to these waters.

9. Crappie

New York offers a good population of Crappies. These are often found in shallow waters throughout the state. The best season to target crappie is in spring and fall. Additionally, some well-known water bodies for catching these fish species are the Niagara River, Great Lakes, Erie Canal, etc. All types of artificial baits work great on these species.

10. Lake Trout

Lake Trout is one of the most caught fish species in New York state. Numerous water bodies offer plenty of these species, with the major ones being the Niagara River, Lake Erie, and Lake Ontario. Lake Ontario and Lake Erie are filled with around 620,000 lake trout each year as part of the Federal Restoration Project.


So, this time if you visit New York, plan a fishing trip into its waters too. You will surely have a great experience.


Fish Descriptions in New York.

Inland Fishes of New York.